Well, welcome
all of you that have come by today.
We appreciate you visiting our booth and
we know you got a lot of things to see here during the show.
So we're grateful you took a few minutes to be with us today.
It's my privilege.
My name is Todd Norton.
I work for Aker BioMarine.
There we go.
I work for Auker Biomarine and handle some business
development activities and some industry relations here.
So it's a privilege and a pleasure for me to just quickly
introduce who we've got here as our panelists today.
We have Ellen Schutt,
who is executive director,
president of GOED.
And then Adam Ismail,
who works with KD Nutra, advisor to the CEO.
We have my colleague Simo Echchafai from Aker BioMarine,
who's handling some growth opportunities for us globally.
And then at the end,
I forgot,
Scott Dicker from SPINS,
who's going to share some information about us.
Share some information with us about activities
that are going on in the retail space.
So you're here
to understand a little bit more,
hopefully,
about the present situation that we face in
the industry with some fish oil disruptions.
And so I'd like to ask a couple of questions of our panelists.
I'd like to start with Ellen first.
GOED,
earlier this year in the summer,
put a webinar together to give a little bit of an update and
an overview of what was going on with the fish oil situation.
And some of the things at that point
were kind of projections at that time.
As the months have gone on,
we've had a few more developments in there,
and the situation has evolved a little bit.
And so maybe,
Ellen,
you could take just a minute to let us know
kind of where things are situated today.
Sure, happy to.
So the Peruvian anchovy fishery is the fishery that supplies the
majority of EPA and DHA oil for the dietary supplement industry.
And they have two fishing seasons.
The first fishing season earlier this year ended early,
and they only caught 25% of the quota that they were expecting.
The second season,
which was supposed to start around now,
has been completely canceled because
of the presence of too many juveniles.
So this is actually a good sustainability story that the Peruvian
fishery is doing the right thing to preserve the future of the category.
And this is really caused by this super El Nino
that we're all experiencing and talking about now.
Thank you.
Adam is with Katie Nitra,
who is by far and away the largest fish oil
supplier to our industry into the category here,
and works with a lot of brands and other people in the value chain.
And so maybe we could just ask Adam kind of what some of
the brand and manufacturers should be paying a little
more closer attention to during this period of disruption.
Yeah,
I mean,
I think the first thing is you should have a backup plan,
right,
to figure out how are you going to
manage your stock and your inventory
and make sure that you have locked in commitments for supply.
The second part of it,
though,
is not just on the supply side,
it's on the demand side.
How are you going to manage your availability and your
ability to stock the shelves if you're in retail or online,
you know,
being sure that you have inventory,
you can continue to win buy boxes because you have stock available.
We've seen a lot of manufacturers and brands in this sector
paying close attention to whether or not consumers are
willing to take on price increases and pass that cost through.
Some brands are increasing prices,
others are keeping them stable because
they're concerned about losing shelf space.
The other thing we've seen is that there's a lot of
companies that are trying to basically buy forward,
lock in inventory for the longer term.
And then I think most interestingly,
you see a lot of brands making decisions about
whether they want to promote or market their Omega-3s
because it's better to just keep shelf space
rather than drive increased uptake of volumes.
Interesting.
Yeah,
a lot of options available and it's not a one size fits all,
that's for sure.
You touched on a couple of things,
Adam and both Ellen here.
I mean,
this is kind of a vulnerable time for the industry and
there's not really one direct or clear way forward here.
You've touched on some of this,
but anything you'd like to add as far as just
how to maybe look at this,
how to plan for this,
as far as specifics.
You've given some great overviews,
but do you have thoughts on ideas for the team here?
Yeah, please.
So GOED has been saying for many years that it's very
important to have a variety of supply choices and options.
And I know we're going to talk about krill and algae here,
but that's just one part of the solution.
And we as GOED,
because we represent the entire category,
we're concerned about the future of the industry broadly.
And we don't want to lose a shelf space.
We want to make sure that there's a variety of
options for all the different consumers of omega-3s.
So I think it's really,
really important that everyone is considering alternative options.
And like Adam said,
really securing your supply for the long term.
The other thing I would say is in 2024,
when we went through the last kind of supply crisis,
if you look at the consumer data in the US,
about 4 million consumers left the category.
4 million.
4 million consumers left the category.
And as Scott pointed out to me right before this,
that was a period where we saw an 8% to 10%
price increase that was passed to the consumer.
Now,
most of those consumers came back when prices returned.
But the demographic that you had the loss the
most consumers in were the 18 to 25-year-olds.
And that's really the future of the industry.
And that demographic didn't come back so quickly.
So if we want to have a long term healthy market,
then we need to very carefully manage how we're going to control
availability and pricing to those consumers so they don't leave forever.
That's a great observation.
That's
a large number.
It really is.
Maybe Simo.
Well,
let's just maybe pivot to Scott if we could here just for a
minute in regards to just what happened at the retail level.
Adam touched on it,
but Scott's with Spins here and he keeps track of a lot
of the activity and data going on in the retail space.
Maybe there's some historical things to be aware of or that we saw,
we observed,
and maybe to help prepare us for this round?
Absolutely.
Everyone hear me okay?
So what we saw is
so far we've seen about a 3% increase in price,
which is
not too bad, standard for a lot of categories.
And it's actually coming off a 2025 where prices decreased.
So that's not a worry.
But when you think about what happened in 2024,
as was mentioned, we saw prices raise 8% to 10%.
So that's what I would expect to see in the next coming quarters.
Historically,
whenever we see major supply chain disruptions in any category,
it usually takes about 12 to 18
months for that to hit retail pricing.
So we see it on the supply side,
people talk about it.
And then there's this waiting period because
brands don't want to be first to raise price.
Retailers put a lot of pressure on them not to raise price.
And so you see that 12 to 18 months usually.
I will note,
though,
that it's not even across the board
in regard to sources as well as products.
With regard to that 3% to 5% increase so far,
we saw that just over half of UPCs have raised prices.
So it's 54% of UPCs have raised prices.
The others have actually decreased prices.
Most of it's just due to, like,
category, normal category.
It wasn't as much mixed shift.
And then also I mentioned fish oil and then also salmon oil
have followed a similar pattern where they increased in 24,
decreased in 25,
and are starting to increase now.
And again, we expect that increase to continue.
Krill oil
actually acted in the opposite way.
So they decreased in 24,
increased in 25,
and have started decreasing again.
And cod liver oil was following that same pattern,
though it's increasing right now.
So there's a few different stories to look at.
With that 8% to 10% increase that we think is coming,
I do think,
I agree with,
and I forgot who said it,
but that the other sources are going to become very important
as we look to stabilize it.
And there's a similar analogy right
now to what's going on with protein,
where whey protein prices are shooting
up where that was the predominant source.
And that means there's an opportunity for other protein
sources which have had not had this similar success to come up.
Same thing for Omega 3 sources.
Very good.
Interesting to hear that.
Thank you.
Simo, maybe just a question for you here.
I mean, as far as just portfolio management,
you're watching this category very closely for us.
Obviously,
we're not a fish oil provider here,
but we feel there's an opportunity,
as Ellen mentioned,
to be a good alternative source,
to be looked at and considered.
I mean,
how are we approaching this or thoughts you'd like to
share about that as brands consider really actually
this act?
I mean, what this needs to look like in action.
Absolutely.
I think our recommendations to the brand is really don't wait for
another crisis to start looking long-term portfolio management.
There is urgency into looking into
stability of supply,
innovation by diversification and long-term growth for the category.
As the colleague said,
we can't afford losing consumers because the prices
are shooting through the roof or because we lose space.
That's not something we can have in the Omega 3 category.
It's been growing steadily for the last 30 years,
and we need to keep with that demand.
So look at the portfolio from a long
-term perspective in terms of having,
you know,
fish oil is a very good source to offer Omega 3s at
a very competitive price for many consumers that
can afford the Omega 3 as a very competitive price.
Right?
We are going through a crisis and maybe a price increase,
but on the long term,
that's the fish oil positioning.
I think algae will bring a different set of consumers.
It's a different value proposition.
It's quite differentiated from fish oil,
and that's the future of the,
I would say,
the supply.
And krill oil is a premium alternative, right?
It's a different story.
It's a multi-nutrient, phospholipid form.
So it's not for everyone,
but it's a premium segment.
So maybe you bring consumers with fish oil and you
take them through other categories like algae and
krill oil in a path of creating different segments.
So that's kind of our recommendation is to look at
all these alternatives as a source of Omega 3 in terms
of reducing the supply reliance on one single source
and in terms of creating new products and innovation in the market
to deal with the consumer expectation in this category.
Very good.
Awesome.
Great advice there.
I think one of the words here we want to have take away is
really just trying to build yourself a resilient portfolio.
As was mentioned, fish oil will be back.
It's a little bit of a difficult time,
but it's also an opportunity,
I think,
to bring in new customers into the category
and have them experience Omega 3s a
little differently maybe than they have.
And again,
we need to kind of help each other out.
I mean,
I know we're all somewhat competitors
here with different sources and whatnot,
but we really do care about the Omega 3 category as a whole.
And we want to see consumers stay.
We want to see the category grow.
And this group here is very mindful of that and doing
everything they can in their own respective businesses.
I don't know if there's any last thoughts or comments
that you want to make just in general on what you heard.
And then maybe we have time for a few questions.
I guess I would say I think one of the challenges,
particularly in the United States,
is that the U.S.
is really a fish oil market.
And when you look at a store shelf,
you see a lot of fish oil products.
And I think I would encourage brands in the audience
to start doing some consumer education around Omega 3s.
And it really needs to be an Omega 3 market because then you
can look at a lot of different sources and still tell a really
strong health story about the importance of EPA and DHA.
Not that consumers know EPA or DHA,
but to tell them the Omega 3 story about all the
important benefits is something that I think we
need to really start thinking about for the future.
Good.
Anyone else?
Scott?
Just to add on to that,
consistently what we hear from retailers is what
incremental buyer are you bringing to the category?
And so in a time if the price in general is going to go
8% to 10% up for fish oil and you could tell that story
that my new source will bring in this new consumer,
that could be a powerful story.
And it's also worth noting that while I said it's 12 to
18 months it usually takes for the prices to hit retail,
so that's a very sticky price before they raise it.
It's even stickier before they come back down.
So it's always something to consider
about where the price point's at,
where it's going to be long term,
and what consumers are willing to pay for each category.
Okay.
Good.
We've got time for probably a couple of questions.
If there's anyone in the audience that
has anything they want to ask or share or
bring up.
Oh, sorry.
Yes.
The panel mentioned that the 2024
shortfall caused an 8% to 10% drop in,
I guess, consumer spending on fish oils.
Was that incorrect?
8% to 10% price increase.
Oh, price increase.
Yes. And then I think you followed that
up with saying that this one is expected,
this shortfall is expected to produce the same,
but this shortfall seems more serious than the last one.
It seems like a double whammy here.
Why wouldn't we be expecting a higher price increase?
So I would be expecting it similar unless it goes further.
I think
there's a limit to how much price increase they could have,
and if next year they have a normal harvest
on it,
I think you might see less promo activity rather than price increase.
So there's other ways that brands
typically pass those prices along.
Some of it is they just decrease their promo.
Some of it is
figuring out a way to position it as premium.
There's shrinkflation that happens
in a lot of these for price per unit.
And also some of the bigger brands will spread the price across
their portfolio so it's not all concentrated on one category.
So that's why I would say I'm expecting
a similar price increase next year.
That doesn't mean that you might not see more price
increase the following year if the circumstances
don't resolve.
The other thing I would add to that is that if you
look at the two major channels for Omega 3 today,
retail and e-commerce.
And e-commerce,
you know, it's about winning the buy box, right?
And you have to make sure that you're
at the top of the search results.
You have to make sure that your price is competitive
enough so that the consumer wants to buy that product.
So there's a little bit of a kind of a who's going
to blink first game going on in e-commerce right now.
And brands are really resisting raising
those prices as long as possible.
But once the leading brands start to do it,
I think you'll see a lot of other brands follow.
And
that's what the difference is.
Well,
so in retail, though,
the bigger issue is that you want to maintain your shelf space.
Because once you lose your shelf space,
you're never going to get it back,
right?
It's very difficult to get it back.
And for retailers, you have alternatives.
It's not about,
oh,
what other Omega 3 product can I put here?
They're looking at the entire supplement shelf and
they'll just replace the fish oil part of this or whatever
with a vitamin or a mineral or an herbal product.
So it's a little bit different.
Whereas in e-commerce,
you know,
you're searching for a specific product
and you don't have that replacement game.
One more?
Anyone?
What other Omega 3 sources other than fish oil?
Are being considered.
So the question was what other Omega 3 sources
other than fish oil are being considered here?
And maybe Simo,
you could just recap if you wouldn't mind.
Yeah, absolutely.
As Ellen said,
there are multiple sources in the industry.
We as IcoBriomarine,
we offer krill oil,
phospholipid based.
We offer algae.
But you can find cod liver oil.
You can find salmon oil.
You can find menadine.
There are different sources,
different specifications,
depending really on what type of positioning in terms of pricing.
And value proposition you would like to offer to the consumers.
There are all different stories from where they come
or the source and the origin of the ingredients.
So it's EPA, DHA, it's Omega 3.
That's the basic story.
But you can also add the flavor that a specific ingredient brings,
right?
With krill, you have the Antarctic sourcing.
You have the Aztexanthine.
You have different sets of ingredients or nutrients.
So each ingredient has a specific story and that I think is what
makes it exciting in terms of product innovation for the category.
Good.
Okay, well, we'll wrap up here.
I'd like to take a minute and thank our panel.
Thank you, Ellen, Adam,
Simo and Scott.
Good content here.
Good things to take away and consider as we go forward.
So thank you.
Thank you as well for coming.